Buying guide·6 min read

Best Olive Oil for Cake: Which One, and Will You Taste It?

The short answer

Decide what the cake should taste of, then choose an extra virgin olive oil to go with it: a fruity, green-tasting one for orange or lemon cake, a bolder one for chocolate, a gentle one for almond. In an olive oil cake, the oil is a flavour as well as a fat.

By Remy Assir ·

What is the best olive oil for cake?

Decide what the cake should taste of, then pick an extra virgin olive oil that goes with it: fruity and green for citrus, bolder for chocolate, gentle for almond.

In an olive oil cake the oil is a flavour, not only a fat. It runs through every slice, so it gets chosen the way you would choose the orange, the cocoa or the almonds: for what it brings to the cake, and for how it sits beside everything else in the bowl.

A neutral oil gives a cake its moisture and stays quiet. An extra virgin olive oil does that job too and has something to say, so the only question is whether it says the right thing. A green, grassy oil can make a lemon cake taste more of lemon. The same oil beside a delicate almond sponge may simply get in the way.

So start with the cake, not the shelf. Read the recipe and find the flavour it is built around. Then taste the oil you have, a few drops on a piece of bread, with that flavour in mind. If the two seem to belong together, you have your oil.

Can you use extra virgin olive oil in cake?

Yes: in a cake recipe written for a neutral oil, you can usually use extra virgin olive oil in the same amount.

"Usually" is there on purpose: not every recipe has been tried that way, so take the first bake as a test. A recipe written as an olive oil cake already names its oil and its amount; the same-amount rule is for the recipe that asks for sunflower or another neutral oil.

What you get is a cake that stays moist. It can also bake up denser, with a closer crumb than a tall, airy sponge, and that is part of its charm: it is a cake for slicing at the table, with coffee or after dinner.

Which olive oil goes with which cake?

Match the oil to the main flavour of the cake: fruity and green with citrus, bold with chocolate, mild with almond, and an oil with some depth for dates and spice.

Citrus and olive oil are a common pairing in cake, and it is the easiest place to start. Chocolate is strong enough to stand beside a bolder oil, almond is gentle and asks for a gentle partner, and dates and spice want an oil that will not disappear under them.

These pairings are our house suggestions, not rules: find your cake in the first column, and read across to the oil to reach for and what you will notice in the slice.

The cake The oil to reach for What you will notice
Orange or lemon A fruity, green-tasting oil The citrus, lifted
Chocolate A bold oil with a peppery bite Deeper chocolate, a little warmth
Almond or semolina A mild, rounded oil The nut first, the oil after
Dates or spice A fruity oil with some depth Warmth that holds up to the spice
Plain yoghurt A gentle, fruity oil A soft tang and a moist crumb

A date cake, cut into small squares for an iftar table, sits happily in the fourth row; the pairing on its own is in dates and olive oil, at iftar and after.

Will the cake taste of olive oil?

A little, and how much depends on the oil you choose and what else goes into the batter.

Bakers find that sugar and flour round off an oil's sharper edges, so a bold oil reads softer in the batter than it does on its own. An oil that catches the back of your throat on bread can come through as a gentle, rounded note in a slice of cake.

Those sharper edges are not faults. The International Olive Council's sensory method for virgin olive oils counts fruity, bitter and pungent as positive attributes, so a bite in the oil is part of its character, not a sign that something went wrong. Here is why good olive oil can taste bitter.

Where the oil goes changes what you notice. Mixed into a batter, it shares the slice with everything else. Poured over a dessert at the table, it sits on top and speaks first, which is a different pleasure, and the subject of olive oil poured over ice cream.

So you can steer it. If you want the oil to show, choose one with more character and keep the other flavours simple. If you would rather it stayed in the background, choose a mild one and let the fruit or the nut lead.

Do you need an expensive olive oil for cake?

No, you need one whose taste you want in the cake, and a price alone cannot tell you that.

A price is what a seller asks. It cannot tell you whether an oil is fruity, mild or bold, and those are the things that end up in the slice. If you want the longer answer, here is what a higher price actually buys.

On any label, look for the grade, a harvest date, a named origin and a code you can look up. Then taste it: the label tells you what the oil is, and only your own taste tells you whether it belongs in this cake.

We make olive oil ourselves. Every KALTA tin carries a BATCH code, and it opens the independent laboratory report for that exact pressing. Every tin carries its harvest date. The batch report page is where that code leads.

Who this is not for

Three readers will want a different page.

  • Someone looking for a full recipe with quantities. This page chooses the oil; it does not give a recipe.
  • Someone baking for a diet. This page says nothing about nutrition.
  • Someone choosing an oil for everyday cooking. That is a different question, with its own page.

The short version

Decide what the cake should taste of, then choose an extra virgin olive oil that goes with it. In a recipe written for a neutral oil, the same amount usually works, and the cake stays moist. You will taste the oil a little, more with a bold one and less with a mild one, because sugar and flour round off its edges. And if the cake is going to someone else's table, here is what to bring with it.

Common questions

Can you use olive oil in a chocolate cake?
Yes, and it is one of the better matches. Dark chocolate is strong enough to stand beside a bolder extra virgin olive oil with a peppery bite; that pairing is a house suggestion, not a rule. If the recipe was written for a neutral oil, you can usually use extra virgin olive oil in the same amount, and the cake will stay moist.
Why is my olive oil cake dense?
An olive oil cake is moist and can bake up denser, with a closer crumb, and that is part of the style rather than a mistake. If you would like a more open crumb, one fix bakers use is to separate the eggs, beat the whites, and fold them into the batter gently at the end. It is a tip, not a rule, and the recipe you are following comes first.
Can you make an olive oil cake ahead?
Yes. A cake made with olive oil stays moist, so it is a good one to make the day before a dinner and leave until the table is ready for it. That also makes it a cake to bring: wrap it, carry it to someone else's table, and slice it there, or leave it whole for the host to cut later.

Remy Assir

Founder, KALTA

Writing about early-harvest, high-polyphenol olive oil — what the numbers mean, why it tastes the way it does, and how to use it.

Explore KALTA →