Lab reports·7 min read

How Olive Oil Polyphenols Are Measured: NMR, HPLC, Folin

The short answer

Three methods are used to measure olive oil polyphenols. Folin-Ciocalteu gives one total from a colour reaction, expressed as caffeic acid. HPLC separates the compounds; the International Olive Council's first method reports them as tyrosol. NMR measures named compounds, such as oleocanthal and oleacein, directly. Each counts differently, so compare numbers within one method only.

By Remy Assir ·

Why do three labs give three different polyphenol numbers?

Because each method counts something different against a different reference compound, so one olive oil can return three different numbers, and a gap between them is not, on its own, a sign that anyone is lying.

A Folin report gives its total as caffeic acid. The International Olive Council's first HPLC method gives its result as tyrosol. NMR reports the named compounds themselves. Three reference points mean three scales, even on one oil, and a number on one scale does not convert into a number on another.

So if you are holding two reports for the same oil, or reading the side of two tins, the first thing to look for is not the size of the number. It is the name of the method beside it.

Folin-Ciocalteu: one total, from a colour reaction

Folin-Ciocalteu is a redox reaction, read as a colour, that is used as a reference method for total polyphenols in food; it gives one total figure, not a list of individual compounds.

That is how a 2023 review by Pérez, Domínguez-López and Lamuela-Raventós in the Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry describes it. On a Folin report the total is expressed as caffeic acid: the whole result is given on a caffeic acid scale, whichever polyphenols in the oil produced it.

Its strength is the single figure. What it cannot tell you, by design, is which polyphenols make up that total.

HPLC: separating the compounds, then adding them up

HPLC, high-performance liquid chromatography, separates an oil extract into its individual compounds before measuring them, and the International Olive Council's declared methods for phenolic compounds are both HPLC methods.

The IOC's method document, COI/T.20/Doc. No 29/Rev.2 (June 2022), declares two. Method 1, published as Doc. No 29/Rev.1 in 2017, reads its results as mg/kg of tyrosol and states a range of 30 to 800 mg/kg. The IOC says it “quantifies using tyrosol and therefore may underestimate the true value”, and that it “may be used to perform a quick determination”.

The IOC's newer method, SPE-HPLC-DAD, is the one it says “can be used to determine the real concentration of phenols to fulfil an EFSA claim”.

That is the IOC being plain about its own quicker method, and it is worth knowing when you see “HPLC tested” on a label: the four letters alone do not tell you which HPLC method was used, or on what scale the result was reported.

NMR: measuring named compounds directly in the oil's extract

Quantitative ¹H NMR, as published for olive oil by a University of Athens group, measures named polyphenols such as oleocanthal and oleacein directly in the oil's extract, without a chromatography step.

Karkoula, Skantzari, Melliou and Magiatis set out the method in the Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry in 2012, and applied it to 175 Greek and Californian single-variety oils. High levels of both compounds went with early harvest.

In 2014 the same group published, in the same journal, a validated extension to the two other major secoiridoids: the monoaldehyde forms of oleuropein aglycon and ligstroside aglycon, measured across 340 oils from 23 varieties over three years. In 2020, Diamantakos, Giannara, Skarkou, Melliou and Magiatis used the method in Molecules to follow total and individual phenols across harvest times and malaxation conditions.

Certificates from the World Olive Center for Health state that their analysis is run at the National and Kapodistrian University of Athens “according to the method that has been submitted to EFET and published in” those three papers. EFET is the Greek food authority.

What you get from NMR is a list rather than one figure: each named compound, then their totals.

Can you compare an NMR number with an HPLC or Folin number?

No: an NMR figure, an HPLC figure and a Folin figure are counted against different references, so set each number only against another from the same method, ideally from the same laboratory.

There is a common argument, made by some sellers and labs that test by HPLC, that NMR reads higher, is “not recognized by the IOC”, and belongs in research rather than on a label. Part of it is right. The IOC's declared methods for phenolic compounds are HPLC methods, and an NMR figure should never be read as if it sat on the same scale as an HPLC or Folin figure.

But chromatographic methods also disagree with each other. Tsimidou and colleagues, in a cross-laboratory study in Molecules in 2019, ran the same oils through five liquid-chromatography protocols and ¹H NMR, in five labs. Absolute values differed. Against the authors' own UHPLC reference, the other protocols showed “slight or statistically significant differences”. The authors favour their UHPLC protocol and stress correction factors in the calculation. The IOC reports the same pattern from its own collaborative tests: “differences were observed when comparing the results obtained by the different methods”.

The fair reading is that different methods produce different numbers, so a figure only means something beside its method. The comparison below sets the three side by side: what each counts, against what reference, who uses it, a limit its source states, and whether its number can be set against the others. None can.

Folin HPLC NMR
What it measures
One total, by colour Separated compounds Named compounds, in the extract
Reference compound
Caffeic acid Tyrosol (IOC Method 1) The compounds themselves
Individual compounds named?
No Yes Yes
Who uses it
Food labs generally The IOC's declared methods Univ. of Athens, World Olive Center
A limit its source states
One total only May underestimate; 30–800 mg/kg Differs from chromatographic results
Compare across methods?
No No No

No column here is the winner. Each is a real measurement, and each needs its method named beside it.

What should you ask for on any polyphenol claim?

Ask for five things beside the number: the method, the laboratory, the report number, the harvest or sample date, and the batch the number belongs to.

A number with all five can be checked, and compared fairly against another made the same way. A number with no method cannot be compared with anything, because you do not know which scale it sits on. For a line-by-line walk through a report, here is how to read an olive oil lab report, and for what the total itself tells you, what a polyphenol count actually means.

Two companion pages go further: why NMR is a valid way to test olive oil polyphenols, and the case against NMR, answered point by point.

Here is what we do. Every batch is tested by an independent laboratory, and we publish the results — the laboratory's name and its report number included. The QR on the tin opens the report for that exact pressing, and the figures themselves are on the batch report for each pressing.

Who is this page not for?

  • A chemist who wants a protocol. The IOC's own method document, COI/T.20/Doc. No 29/Rev.2, is where its HPLC methods are set out.
  • Someone looking for what polyphenols do for health. This is a page about measurement; the research is on what the research says about Picual olive oil.
  • Someone who wants our own numbers. None of them are on this page. Each one is on the trace page for its batch.

Common questions

Which is more accurate, NMR or HPLC?
Neither one, as a verdict: they measure differently. NMR measures named compounds directly; the International Olive Council's first HPLC method reports a total as tyrosol and, in its own words, “may underestimate the true value”. A 2019 cross-lab study by Tsimidou and colleagues found absolute values differed between methods. Compare like with like: the same method, ideally from the same lab.
Why is my olive oil's polyphenol number different on two reports?
Because the two reports may use different methods, and different methods give different numbers for the same oil. A Folin report gives one total as caffeic acid; the International Olive Council's first HPLC method gives a total as tyrosol; NMR reports named compounds themselves. Labs using different chromatographic protocols can also disagree (Tsimidou and colleagues, Molecules, 2019).
What does 'as tyrosol' or 'as caffeic acid' mean?
It names the reference compound the result is expressed in. A Folin total is given as caffeic acid; the International Olive Council's first HPLC method gives its result as tyrosol. Each number sits on its own compound's scale, so a total “as caffeic acid” and a total “as tyrosol” are different measurements and do not convert into each other. NMR names each compound itself.

Remy Assir

Founder, KALTA

Writing about early-harvest, high-polyphenol olive oil — what the numbers mean, why it tastes the way it does, and how to use it.

Explore KALTA →