Buying guide·7 min read
Best Olive Oil for Salad, and How to Dress One
The best olive oil for salad is an extra virgin olive oil you would happily taste from a spoon. Match its strength to the salad: delicate for soft leaves and fruit, robust for rocket, tomatoes, beans and grains, medium if you keep one oil. Dress mostly with oil, just before serving.
The leaves are washed, the bowl is out, and people are nearly at the table. One choice is left before the salad goes out: the olive oil. Here is which one to use, how strong it should be, and how to dress the bowl so every leaf tastes of something.
What is the best olive oil for salad?
The best olive oil for salad is an extra virgin olive oil you would happily taste from a spoon, because on a salad the oil is tasted as it is, with nothing to hide behind.
Extra virgin is the grade with a flavour of its own, and a salad puts that flavour right out in front. There is no sauce to soften it and no other ingredient to cover it: the first forkful tastes of the leaves, the lemon and the oil together.
The simplest test is one you can do right now. Pour a few drops onto a spoon and taste them. If you would enjoy that oil on its own, it will be good on the leaves; if you would not, no dressing will hide it.
If you are choosing an extra virgin olive oil at the shelf, start with how to tell whether an olive oil is what it says, then read what the grade names on olive oil mean.
Should the olive oil match the salad?
Yes: olive oils run from delicate to robust, and a delicate oil suits soft leaves and fruit, while a robust one stands up to rocket, tomatoes, beans and grains.
What sets one oil apart from another is how strongly three things come through: the fruit, the bitterness and the pepper. A delicate oil is gentle on all three, a medium oil has clear fruit with some bite, and a robust oil brings plenty of each. Match that strength to the salad, and neither the oil nor the leaves get lost.
| The oil | What you taste | Salads it suits |
|---|---|---|
| Delicate | Gentle fruit, little bitterness | Soft leaves, fruit, fresh cheese |
| Medium | Clear fruit, some bitterness and pepper | Most salads, if you keep one oil |
| Robust | Strong fruit, bitterness and pepper | Rocket, tomatoes, beans and grains |
The reason is balance. A delicate oil disappears under rocket and ripe tomatoes, while a robust one can take over a plate of soft leaves and fruit. When they are matched, you taste both the salad and the oil.
If a robust oil tastes bitter and peppery from the spoon, nothing is wrong: bitterness and pepper are good signs in an extra virgin oil. There is more on when bitterness in olive oil is a good sign.
If you keep only one oil, make it a medium one. It has enough fruit for soft leaves and enough pepper for a bowl of tomatoes and beans, so it suits the most salads.
How do you make a simple olive oil dressing?
A simple dressing is mostly olive oil, a smaller splash of lemon juice or vinegar, and salt dissolved in the lemon or vinegar first; shake it in a jar or whisk it, then taste it on a leaf.
Start with the salt, because salt dissolves in lemon juice and vinegar but not in oil. Stir a pinch into the lemon or vinegar at the bottom of the jar until it disappears, and the dressing will taste evenly seasoned instead of gritty in one bite and flat in the next.
Then pour in the olive oil, and be generous: the oil is most of the dressing, and the lemon or vinegar is the bright edge on it. Because the oil carries the flavour, the dressing tastes of whichever oil you pour.
Oil and lemon or vinegar do not stay mixed, so shake the jar hard or whisk just before you pour. Then dip a leaf in and taste it. Dressing tasted from a spoon usually seems sharper than it will on the salad; on a leaf, you taste what your guests will.
Adjust from there: a little more oil if it bites, a squeeze more lemon if it tastes flat, another pinch of salt, shaken in, if the flavours seem muted.
When should you dress a salad?
Dress a salad just before it goes to the table, tossing the leaves in the bowl until every leaf shines, because leaves dressed early go limp.
Soft leaves are the first to wilt, so a salad dressed too soon can sit flat in the bowl before anyone reaches for it. Crisp leaves hold up a little better, but every salad is at its best when the dressing goes on last.
Put the heavier things, such as tomatoes, beans or grains, in the bowl first and the leaves on top. Pour the dressing around the side of the bowl rather than onto the top, then lift and turn everything with your hands or two spoons until each leaf shines.
Putting bread on the table beside the salad as well? The dish of oil for it is its own small decision, and choosing an olive oil for dipping bread walks through it. If a soft cheese is going out too, olive oil for burrata covers how to serve that.
How much olive oil goes on a salad?
Use enough olive oil to give every leaf a thin coat, with none pooling in the bottom of the bowl; add a little, toss, and add more only if a leaf tastes dry.
It is easier to add dressing than to take it away. A puddle at the bottom of the bowl means the leaves are sitting in more than they can hold, and the last helpings come out soggy.
Toss properly before you judge. Leaves that look bare after one turn often shine after a few more, once the dressing has had a chance to travel. Taste a leaf from the middle of the bowl: if it is dry, add a little more and toss again.
A big bowl for a crowd takes more than you might expect, and a small plate of soft leaves takes less. Go by the leaf, not by the recipe.
Who this is not for
This page will not suit three readers, and it is better to say so plainly.
- Someone who wants a salad recipe with exact measures. This page is about the oil and the dressing, not a recipe card.
- Someone who wants a ranking of olive oil brands. We make olive oil ourselves, so a ranking from us could never be neutral.
- Someone who wants a dressing with no oil in it. This page builds the dressing around olive oil. A squeeze of lemon and a pinch of salt on their own are a fine choice too, and a different one.
The short version
For salad, choose an extra virgin olive oil you would taste from a spoon, and match its strength to the leaves: delicate for soft leaves, robust for rocket, tomatoes, beans and grains, medium if you keep only one. Make the dressing mostly oil, with salt dissolved in a splash of lemon or vinegar first. Dress the bowl just before it goes to the table, and stop when every leaf has a thin coat. Then taste your oils side by side with a simple olive oil tasting at home, and you will know which one each salad wants.