Buying guide·6 min read
Best Olive Oil for Burrata, and How to Serve It
The best olive oil for burrata is a medium extra virgin olive oil, spooned over the burrata once it is opened at the table, with flaky salt and bread alongside. Go delicate when the cheese is on its own, and robust when rocket or olives join the plate.
Friends are on their way, the burrata is on the counter, and the plate needs nothing from the stove. All it asks for is a good olive oil, a pinch of salt and a place in the middle of the table. Here is which oil to choose, how to serve it, and how to turn it into a dip.
What is the best olive oil for burrata?
The best olive oil for burrata is a medium extra virgin, poured over the cheese once it is opened at the table; go delicate when the burrata is on its own, and robust when the plate gets louder.
Burrata gives an oil nowhere to hide. It is a soft, mild cheese, and whatever you pour over it sits right out in front, with nothing else on the plate to cover for it. So the simplest test is whether you would enjoy the oil from a spoon: if you would, it will taste good on burrata.
That is why the grade matters here. Extra virgin is the grade with a flavour of its own, and on burrata that flavour is exactly what you are pouring. If you have ever wondered how the olive oil grades differ, there is a plain-words page on it.
Which olive oil is best for your burrata depends on what else is on the plate, and the next section turns that into a simple rule.
Should the oil match what is on the plate?
Yes: burrata is mild, so match the oil to the strongest thing beside it on the plate.
Olive oils run from delicate to medium to robust, depending on how strongly their fruit, bitterness and pepper come through. On its own, a mild cheese suits a delicate or medium oil, which brings soft fruit and lets the burrata lead. When tomatoes, rocket or olives join it, the plate gets louder, and the oil has to keep up. Here is the plain rule, plate by plate.
| On the plate | The oil | What it does |
|---|---|---|
| Burrata on its own | Delicate or medium | Soft fruit that lets the cheese lead |
| With tomato and basil | Medium | Fruit and pepper to meet the tomato |
| With rocket or olives | Robust | Enough pepper to be tasted |
A robust oil can taste bitter and peppery straight from the spoon, and that is nothing to worry about: bitterness and pepper are good signs in an extra virgin oil, and here is what bitterness in olive oil tells you.
Tomatoes ask for an oil with enough fruit and pepper to meet them, and it is the same matching that sits behind how to dress a salad with olive oil.
Keeping only one oil? A medium extra virgin covers most plates, and it is the easy answer when you do not yet know what else is coming to the table.
How do you serve burrata with olive oil?
Set the burrata whole on a plate, open it at the table, spoon olive oil over it, add a pinch of flaky salt and a little black pepper, and serve it straight away.
Choose a plate with a little room around the burrata, so the oil has somewhere to gather. Bring the burrata to the table whole and open it there with a spoon; that moment is half the reason to serve it. Then spoon the oil over the top, generously, so it runs down the sides and collects on the plate.
Finish with a pinch of flaky salt, crumbled between your fingers so it falls across the top, and a little black pepper. Salt and pepper are the usual finish, and with the oil they are everything a plain burrata asks for.
Put bread alongside, because someone will want to wipe up the oil left on the plate; if the bread becomes the main event, there is a whole page on olive oil for dipping bread.
How do you make a burrata and olive oil dip?
Tear the burrata into a shallow bowl, pour olive oil around it until it pools, add salt and pepper, and put bread alongside for scooping.
It is the same burrata, made easier to share. Torn into pieces, it sits in a pool of oil, and every piece of bread comes up with cheese and oil together.
Use a bowl that is wide rather than deep, so the oil spreads out and every piece of bread can reach it. Tear the burrata with your hands or two forks and let the pieces fall where they like. Pour the oil around them rather than over them, until it pools in the bottom of the bowl, then finish with flaky salt and black pepper.
Set the bowl in the middle of the table with the bread around it. This is the burrata for a table that would rather dip than wait for a knife.
How do you serve it to a table of friends?
Put one burrata in the middle of the table with the olive oil and a little dish of flaky salt beside it, open it together, and let everyone tear and pour their own.
It turns a starter into something the table does together. Someone goes first and opens it; after that, people tear a piece, pour a little oil over it, add a pinch of salt and pass the oil along. Some go gently with the oil and some pour, and both are right.
If you have two oils open, put both out side by side over the same burrata, a delicate one and a robust one, so everyone can taste the difference on one plate. It is a small, savoury version of an olive oil tasting at home.
And when the plate is wiped clean and the table wants something sweet, the same oil and the same salt can go straight onto dessert: here is olive oil on ice cream.
Who this is not for
Three readers will want a different page from this one, and it is fairer to say so here.
- Someone looking for a recipe that cooks the burrata. This page is about burrata served as it is.
- Someone who wants a ranking of olive oil brands. We make olive oil ourselves, so a ranking from us could never be neutral.
- Someone who wants to know where to buy burrata. This page starts once the burrata is on your counter.
The short version
Open the burrata at the table, spoon the oil over it so it pools, and finish with flaky salt and a little black pepper, with bread alongside. Match the oil to the strongest thing on the plate: delicate or medium for burrata on its own, medium with tomato and basil, robust with rocket or olives, and medium if you keep only one. For a dip, tear it into a shallow bowl, let the oil pool around it, and put the bread where everyone can reach it.