Hosting·6 min read

Best Olive Oil for Soup: Which One, and Where It Goes

The short answer

Pour a thin line of extra virgin olive oil over each bowl of soup just before it reaches the table, and choose that oil by taste, because it sits on top and is the first thing anyone notices. Extra virgin is the usual oil over soup, and the same one can go into the soup while it is made.

By Remy Assir ·

What is the best olive oil for soup?

Pour a thin line of extra virgin olive oil over each bowl just before it is carried to the table, and choose the oil by taste, because on top of the soup it is what people notice first.

Extra virgin olive oil is the oil people usually pour over soup, and it is an everyday oil for the kitchen, at work while a soup is being made as well as on top. Over the bowl nothing stands between the oil and the person eating, so its taste is the thing to choose by.

Over a bowl of soup, the oil is the part nobody misses: it rests on the surface, carries its own aroma, and reaches each guest ahead of everything beneath it.

That makes the choice a matter of taste. There is no single right oil for every soup; there is the one you and the people at your table enjoy.

We make olive oil ourselves. Every KALTA tin carries a BATCH code, and it opens the independent laboratory report for that exact pressing. Every tin carries its harvest date. The batch report page is the place to read it.

Does olive oil go in the soup or on top?

Both: many soups start with olive oil in the pot, and a little more goes over each bowl when it is served, where its taste comes through most.

The same extra virgin can do both, so one oil you like is all a soup needs.

For the many other places olive oil goes in a kitchen, here is which olive oil to cook with.

Which soups take olive oil on top, and what goes with it?

Most do, especially lentil, bean, tomato and vegetable soups: a thin line of oil over the bowl, then one other thing, such as lemon, herbs or black pepper.

The table below sets six soups side by side, with where the oil goes in each and one or two things to add. Each row is our suggestion, and every one bends to what you have in the kitchen. In short: lentil, white bean and chickpea take oil in the making and over each bowl; tomato, vegetable and pumpkin take it over each bowl.

Soup Where the oil goes What goes with it
Lentil In the pot, and over each bowl Lemon and a pinch of cumin
Tomato Over each bowl Torn basil and black pepper
White bean In the pot, and over each bowl A sprig of rosemary
Chickpea In the pot, and over each bowl Lemon and chopped parsley
Vegetable Over each bowl Grated hard cheese
Pumpkin A thin line over each bowl Pumpkin seeds and black pepper

Lentil soup takes olive oil at both ends: in the making, and over each bowl, with a squeeze of lemon and a pinch of cumin set out beside it. It is often on the table at iftar, and if you are setting that table, there is more in dates and olive oil.

A smooth tomato soup shows the line of oil clearly across the red. Tear basil leaves over it at the last moment and add black pepper; nothing more is needed.

White bean and chickpea soups are thick and soft in taste, and they welcome oil in the making as well as over the bowl. Rosemary suits the beans; lemon and parsley lift the chickpeas.

A vegetable soup or a pumpkin soup needs nothing beyond the oil and what its row suggests; pumpkin is the sweetest of the six, so the black pepper matters.

How do you serve soup at a dinner party?

Bring the soup to the table in a pot or tureen, ladle it into bowls there, and set out a small jug of olive oil, lemon wedges and a few toppings so people make their own bowl.

Put a few toppings out in small bowls rather than every one you can think of; for a bigger group, a row of them along the table becomes a toppings bar.

Ladling at the table puts everyone in their seats at the same moment, and the jug of oil can travel round so each person adds as much as they like.

Lemon wedges sit well beside the jug, since lemon and olive oil go together on many soups.

Soup is often the first course of several, so keep it simple and let the dishes after it bring the variety; if more small dishes are coming next, here is how to put together a mezze platter.

Does a peppery olive oil work on soup?

Yes, on most soups: a little pepper and fruit in the oil stands up well to lentils, beans and tomato.

Pepper in an extra virgin olive oil is a good sign, not a flaw, and oils differ in how much of it they carry; to understand it, read what a peppery olive oil tells you.

On pumpkin, the sweetest soup on the list, a peppery oil gives the bowl an edge it would otherwise miss.

If the people at your table like their oil gentler, choose a gentler one: the soup is for them, and their taste decides.

Who this is not for

Three kinds of reader are better served somewhere else.

  • Someone who wants a soup recipe with exact measures. This page is about the oil and the table, not a recipe card.
  • Someone who wants a ranking of olive oil brands. We make olive oil ourselves, so a ranking from us could never be neutral.
  • Someone looking for an olive oil with other things steeped in it. This page is about plain extra virgin olive oil.

The short version

Use one extra virgin olive oil whose taste you enjoy, in the making of the soup and over each bowl. Pour a thin line on top just before the bowls reach the table, with lemon, herbs or black pepper beside it. For a dinner party, ladle at the table and set out a jug of oil and a few toppings, so everyone makes their own bowl.

Common questions

Why do people put olive oil on soup?
It adds flavour and aroma, and lays a silky line across the top of the bowl. Poured over each bowl when the soup is served, the oil sits on the surface, so it is the first thing you taste. That is also why the oil is chosen by taste: on top of a soup it has nowhere to hide.
What olive oil goes on tomato soup?
An extra virgin olive oil you enjoy, ideally one with a little fruit and pepper, which stands up well to the tomato. Pour a thin line over each bowl when it is served and add torn basil leaves and black pepper. The leaves give the basil; the oil can stay plain.
Do you put olive oil on lentil soup?
Yes. Many cooks start lentil soup with olive oil in the pot, then pour a little more over each bowl when it is served, with a squeeze of lemon beside it. The oil and lemon together lift the lentils, and a small jug on the table lets everyone add more to their own bowl.

Remy Assir

Founder, KALTA

Writing about early-harvest, high-polyphenol olive oil — what the numbers mean, why it tastes the way it does, and how to use it.

Explore KALTA →