Buying Guide·7 min read
Olive Oil Grades Explained: Extra Virgin, Virgin, "Pure" and Pomace
The olive oil grades are extra virgin, virgin, refined olive oil, "olive oil" (a blend of refined and virgin oils) and olive-pomace oil. Extra virgin and virgin come from the fruit by mechanical means alone; extra virgin has no flavour fault. "Pure" and "light" are not grade names.
One shelf can hold "extra virgin", "virgin", "olive oil", "pure", "light" and "pomace", often in containers that look much alike. They are not six versions of one oil. Here is what each name means, what each tastes of, and which one to reach for in your kitchen.
What are the olive oil grades?
The international food standard for olive oils names the grades you will meet on a shelf: extra virgin, virgin, refined olive oil, "olive oil" (a blend of refined and virgin oils) and olive-pomace oil.
They fall into three families. Two are virgin oils, which come from the fruit by mechanical means alone: extra virgin and virgin. One is refined olive oil on its own, which tastes of very little. And two are blends of refined oil with some virgin oil added: the grade simply called "olive oil", and olive-pomace oil, which starts from a different material altogether.
The names matter because they are not interchangeable. Each one tells you how the oil was made and, from that, roughly how much it will taste of olives. When these names sit side by side on a shelf, the grade name is the first word to read.
What is the difference between extra virgin and virgin olive oil?
Both come from the fruit by mechanical means alone, but extra virgin is the one in which a tasting panel finds no flavour fault, while virgin olive oil is allowed small faults.
"Mechanical means alone" is what makes an oil virgin. The oil comes from the fruit, and nothing is done to it afterwards beyond washing, settling, centrifuging and filtering. Extra virgin and virgin both meet that line.
What separates them is taste. A tasting panel samples the oil. Extra virgin has to show some fruitiness and no flavour fault at all. Virgin olive oil may carry small faults, so it still tastes of olives, but less cleanly.
So the grade name tells you, before you open anything, how much olive flavour you are buying. Here is the whole shelf in one place:
| On the label | What it is | Tastes of |
|---|---|---|
| Extra virgin | Fruit only, no flavour fault | Olives: green, peppery, fruity |
| Virgin | Fruit only, small faults allowed | Olives, less cleanly |
| "Olive oil" / "pure" | Refined oil plus some virgin | Very little |
| "Light" | Same grade as "olive oil" | Even less |
| Olive-pomace oil | Refined from the residue | Very little |
Read down the third column and the pattern is plain: the further an oil is from the fruit alone, the less it tastes of olives. Neither end of the table is wrong. Which one you want depends on what you want the oil to do.
What does "pure" or "light" olive oil mean?
Neither "pure" nor "light" is a grade name: both are sold under the grade called "olive oil", a blend of refined and virgin oils, and "light" describes the flavour.
Look for the grade name elsewhere on the same label. If it reads "olive oil", that is the oil you are holding, whichever word sits above it.
"Light" is about taste. It means a milder oil, with less olive flavour than extra virgin, and it refers to nothing else about the oil.
"Pure" is a word on the front, not a grade. It does not place the oil above extra virgin, and it does not place it in a grade of its own. On the label it sits on the blend called "olive oil".
A grade name is only worth something when it is true, and there is more on how grade fraud works. To check a label while you are standing at the shelf, here is how to tell if olive oil is original.
What is pomace olive oil?
Pomace olive oil is oil made from the pomace, the solid residue left once the oil has been extracted; it is refined, then blended with virgin oil, and may never be sold as plain "olive oil".
On the label it is called "olive-pomace oil", never plain "olive oil". That name is what keeps it apart from the grade called "olive oil", even though both are blends with some virgin oil in them.
Because it is refined, it tastes of very little, much like the blend sold as "olive oil". It is a different product from extra virgin, with a different starting point, and it suits a different job: the dishes where the cook wants an oil that does not taste of olives.
You do not need to know how it is made to choose well. You need the name. If the label says pomace, the oil started from what was left after the first oil came out of the fruit, not from the fruit itself.
Which grade should you buy for what?
Buy extra virgin for anywhere you taste the oil, such as bread, salads and a finished plate, and for everyday cooking too; choose a refined grade when you want no olive flavour at all.
Extra virgin is the grade with a flavour of its own: grassy, green and peppery. Wherever the oil is out in front, that flavour is the point. It is the oil for a dish of bread, for dressing leaves, and for the spoonful over soup or a plate of beans just before it goes to the table. There is more on choosing an olive oil for dipping bread and on how to dress a salad with olive oil.
Extra virgin is an everyday cooking oil as well as a finishing one. Use it for sautéing onions, for roasting vegetables, for a fried egg on a weekday morning. The flavour it brings to the pan carries through to the plate.
Refined grades, whether labelled "olive oil", "light" or olive-pomace oil, taste of very little. That suits a cook who wants no olive flavour in a dish, and for that job it is a fair choice.
If you keep one oil, make it extra virgin: it does the tasting jobs and the everyday ones. If you keep two, the second can be a refined grade for the dishes where you want the oil to stay in the background.
Every KALTA tin carries a BATCH code, and it opens the independent laboratory report for that exact pressing. To read one, look up a batch.
Who this is not for
This page will not suit three readers, and it is better to say so plainly.
- Someone who wants the chemistry. The laboratory limits behind each grade are not on this page. The grade names, and what they mean in your kitchen, are.
- Someone comparing named brands. We name and rank none. We make olive oil ourselves, so a ranking from us could never be neutral.
- Someone choosing an oil for a beauty routine. This page is about oil you eat.
The short version
Extra virgin and virgin come from the fruit by mechanical means alone, and extra virgin is the one with no flavour fault. "Olive oil", "pure" and "light" all sit on a blend of refined and virgin oils, and olive-pomace oil starts from the residue left once the oil is out. Buy extra virgin wherever you taste the oil and for everyday cooking, and a refined grade when you want no olive flavour. Read the grade name, not the word above it.