Buying guide·7 min read
Best Olive Oil for Pasta: In the Pan and at the Table
The best olive oil for pasta is an extra virgin olive oil whose taste you like. Match its strength to the sauce: delicate for lemon and seafood, medium for tomato sauces, robust for pesto and chilli. Skip the oil in the pasta water; use it to start the sauce and finish each bowl.
The water is on, the bowls are stacked and people are on their way. Pasta for a crowd is one of the easiest ways to feed friends well, and the olive oil does more of the work than it gets credit for. Here is which one to use, and where it goes: the pan, the water and the bowl.
Which olive oil is best for pasta?
The best olive oil for pasta is an extra virgin olive oil whose taste you like, because pasta carries the oil twice: in the pan, where the sauce starts, and over the bowl at the table.
Extra virgin olive oil is an everyday oil for the stove as well as for the table, and a pot of pasta is one of its most ordinary jobs. Extra virgin is also the grade with a flavour of its own, and a bowl of pasta gives that flavour two chances to show: once in the sauce, and once on top.
In the pan, the oil is the first thing the sauce is built on, so it carries through everything that follows. Over the bowl, it is tasted as it is, right before the first forkful.
The quickest check is a spoon: taste a few drops, and if you would enjoy that oil on its own, it will be good over the pasta. Not sure what makes an oil extra virgin in the first place? Here is what the olive oil grades mean.
Which olive oil suits which pasta?
Match the oil's strength to the sauce: a delicate oil for lemon, seafood and soft cheese, a medium one for tomato sauces, and a robust one for pesto, greens, beans and chilli.
Olive oils run from delicate to medium to robust, depending on how strongly three things come through: the fruit, the bitterness and the pepper. A delicate oil should not cover the food, so it suits gentle bowls of lemon, seafood or soft cheese. A medium oil is the everyday choice for a tomato sauce. A robust oil stands up to strong flavours that would flatten anything gentler.
| The oil | What you taste | Pasta it suits |
|---|---|---|
| Delicate | Gentle fruit, little bitterness | Lemon, seafood, soft cheese |
| Medium | Clear fruit, some pepper | Tomato sauces, most everyday bowls |
| Robust | Strong fruit, bitterness and pepper | Pesto, greens, beans, chilli |
A robust oil can taste sharply bitter and peppery from the spoon, and nothing is wrong with it: both are good signs in an extra virgin oil, and there is more on when bitterness in olive oil is a good sign.
Keeping only one oil? A medium one covers the widest range of pasta, with enough fruit for lemon and seafood and enough pepper for a tomato sauce.
And if a green salad is going out beside the pasta, here is how to dress a salad with olive oil.
Should you put olive oil in the pasta water?
No, it is not needed: the oil floats on the water, so little of it reaches the pasta, and stirring early is what stops the pasta sticking.
Oil and water do not mix. Oil is less dense than water, so a pour of it into the pot simply floats on the surface while the pasta tumbles underneath. When you drain the pasta, most of that oil goes down the sink with the water, and very little of it ever coats the pasta.
What stops pasta sticking is stirring. Give the pot a good stir as soon as the pasta goes in, and again now and then as it cooks, so the pieces never settle into a clump.
So put the oil where it does real work: in the pan, where it starts the sauce, and over the bowl, where it goes on last.
How do you make a simple olive oil pasta sauce?
Start garlic and chilli in a generous pour of olive oil, stop when the garlic turns pale gold, then toss in the drained pasta with a splash of its cooking water so the oil turns into a sauce that clings.
This is the simplest oil pasta there is, and in its plainest form it goes by the name aglio e olio. Slice the garlic, put it in the pan with the chilli and a generous pour of olive oil, and stir as it cooks. Watch the garlic rather than the clock: the moment it turns pale gold, it is ready for the pasta.
Before you drain the pasta, scoop out a splash of its cooking water. Tip the drained pasta into the pan, add that splash and toss everything together. The starch in the water helps the oil and water bind, and what was a pool of oil turns into a glossy sauce that clings to every strand. If it looks dry, add another splash and toss again.
The same start, oil in the pan first and everything else after, sits under plenty of other dishes; for those, here is which olive oil is good for cooking.
Should you add olive oil after cooking?
Yes: a spoon of good extra virgin olive oil over each bowl, just before it goes to the table, puts the olive flavour back on top.
The oil in the pan has already done its job: it built the sauce and is part of the dish now. The spoon at the end does something different. It sits on top, it is the first thing you taste, and it puts the olive flavour back where everyone can find it. One builds the bowl and the other finishes it, and a good bowl of pasta has both.
It works on almost any pasta. A gentle oil suits a bowl of lemon and seafood, a medium one suits a tomato sauce, and a bolder one suits beans, greens and chilli. If you only have the one oil you cooked with, use that: it is the same oil, doing a second job.
Put the oil on the table too, so people can add a little more to their own bowls.
Who this is not for
Three readers will want a different page from this one, and it is fairer to say so here.
- Someone who wants a full pasta recipe with exact measures. This page is about the oil and where it goes, not a recipe card.
- Someone who wants a ranking of olive oil brands. We make olive oil ourselves, so a ranking from us could never be neutral.
- Someone making pasta dough at home. Whether oil goes into the dough is a dough question, and this page is about the oil on and around cooked pasta.
The short version
For pasta, choose an extra virgin olive oil you like, and match its strength to the sauce: delicate for lemon and seafood, medium for tomato, robust for pesto, greens and chilli, and medium if you keep only one. Leave it out of the pasta water and stir instead. Start the sauce in a generous pour, toss it with a splash of the cooking water, and finish each bowl with a spoon of good oil at the table. Then taste two oils side by side with a simple olive oil tasting at home, and you will know which one your pasta wants.